Chalets vs Apartments for Rental Returns: A quick overview of Alpine Property
The French Alps, that playground of the perpetually tanned and terminally wealthy, presents a curious study in property rental patterns. Like the difference between a Range Rover and a Mini Cooper, both chalets and apartments serve their purpose admirably—though one rather suspects their owners would prefer not to be seen in the latter.
When Winter Reigns Supreme
The Alpine season runs with the precision of a Swiss timepiece from mid-December to mid-April, though one might argue it operates more like a Victorian railway—punctual for the privileged, rather less accommodating for everyone else. During these 16 weeks of potential winter bookings, both property types compete for their share of what amounts to 85% of annual rental income.
Chalets behave rather like debutantes at a coming-out ball: absolutely dazzling during the key social events, then sulking in empty splendour between engagements. In Val d’Isère, chalets command an eye-watering €29,023/m² compared to apartments at a merely shocking €19,620/m²—a €9,403/m² premium that would make even a Mayfair estate agent blush.
Apartments, by contrast, display the admirable consistency of a well-trained butler. They welcome couples, small groups, and the occasional business traveller with equal aplomb, accommodating 3-4 night stays that chalets—with their lofty operational costs of €6,250-€18,750 annually versus apartments’ modest €3,750-€10,000—would consider frightfully beneath their dignity.
The Mathematics of Misery and Joy
Both property types manage approximately 12 weeks of winter bookings annually, though the distribution resembles the difference between a champagne reception and a steady pension. Summer adds another 6 weeks of bookings in July and August, traditionally generating a paltry 15% of annual rental income compared to winter’s commanding 85%.
However, one notes with considerable interest that this pattern is shifting rather dramatically. Summer occupancy in Châtel has spiked from 40-50% to 90% in August since COVID, while the Portes du Soleil now operates lifts from mid-May to mid-September compared to just six weeks in 2010.
Chalets concentrate their earnings like a hedge fund manager concentrates risk—spectacularly and with considerable gaps in between. Apartments in Chamonix average €10,410/m² while chalets reach €13,665/m²—a €3,255/m² premium that translates to substantially different cash flows.
Apartments spread their occupancy with the reliability of afternoon tea at Fortnum’s. In Morzine, apartment prices have grown 10% annually since 2023, now ranging €8,193/m² compared to chalets at €10,546/m²—a more manageable €2,353/m² gap that makes yield calculations rather less painful.
Regional Mathematics
The financial disparities vary considerably by postcode, rather like property prices between Belgravia and Birmingham. Also, do note that on average, new-builds increase these prices by 15%.
Prime luxury markets show the most dramatic gaps:
Val d’Isère: Apartments €19,620/m², chalets €29,023/m² (+48% premium)
Courchevel: Apartments €16,000/m², chalets €17,749/m² (+11% premium)
Méribel: Apartments €15,545/m², chalets €17,831/m² (+15% premium)
Sensible middle-tier resorts offer more reasonable disparities:
Morzine: Apartments €8,193/m², chalets €10,546/m² (+29% premium)
Les Gets: Apartments €8,838/m², chalets €10,771/m² (+22% premium)
Tignes: Apartments €10,609/m², chalets €12,333/m² (+16% premium)
The Appreciation Game
Properties above 1,500 metres altitude have risen 40% over ten years—double the rate of their low-altitude cousins. The Northern Alps have experienced 20% price growth in just three years, with apartments at €4,468/m² and chalets at €5,331/m².
Meanwhile, the Southern Alps show more modest 6% annual growth, with apartments averaging €2,925/m² and chalets €3,168/m²—figures that might actually allow one to buy something without mortgaging the family estate.
The Burden of Excellence
Managing these properties creates distinct financial obligations that differ rather like maintaining a Georgian townhouse versus a Victorian cottage:
Chalets demand annual maintenance budgets of €6,250-€18,750, resembling the upkeep costs of a small stately home. They require the sort of intensive management typically reserved for launching a debutante—everything happens at once during peak weeks, costs a fortune, and success depends entirely on avoiding catastrophic failures when weekly rates can reach €18,750-€31,250.
Apartments require annual maintenance of €3,750-€10,000—the difference between keeping a racehorse and a reliable hack. Their 3-5% net yields consistently outperform chalets’ 1-3% returns, providing the sort of dependable income that built the Empire.
Seasonal Revenue Realities
The most telling statistic concerns the concentration of earnings: chalets typically achieve 2-3 week gaps between premium bookings, while apartments maintain more consistent occupancy throughout the 16-week winter window. This translates to chalets requiring cash reserves to cover 6-8 weeks of vacancy between peak periods—roughly the cost of running a small country house through a particularly expensive winter.
Summer transformation has been remarkable: year-on-year increases in overnight stays since 2015 have extended what were once 12-week earning seasons to potentially 20+ weeks annually. However, apartments capture more of this extended demand due to their operational flexibility and democratic appeal to the growing number of Middle Eastern clients seeking Alpine summers and Americans fleeing Arizona’s surface-of-Venus temperatures.
The arithmetic is rather stark: choose chalets for prestige and capital appreciation (with the requisite deep pockets), or apartments for reliable yields and sensible cash flow. Rather like the eternal choice between keeping a proper country estate or a comfortable London flat—both serve their purpose, but one requires considerably more from the bank manager.
Quick search
Abondance | Les Chalets des Cimes
2246 Thollon-les-Memises | Full Chalet Lake Views Metres From The...
Morzine | Les Dents Blanches
Ready to Buy your ski Home?
Get in touch with our French Alps team to secure your ideal ski property.
Domosno — member of the
Association of International Property Professionals
since 2010
